A Broken Model Isn't a Broken Owner

Nobody wants to say it out loud.

Not to their spouse, not to their employees, and definitely not to the people in town who have been shopping with them for years. Closing a business feels like quitting. It feels like admitting you weren't good enough.

So most owners don't say it. They move a little money from savings. They tell themselves next quarter will be different. And they keep the lights on long after the business has stopped telling them it wants to stay open.

In a recent episode of the Planting Seeds Podcast, Nick and I took on one of the hardest questions we've tackled so far: when is it time to close the doors?

Nick laid out the practical side, from spotting the trend to deciding ahead of time how much of your own money you're willing to put in. He walks through all of it in [his write-up of the episode]. I want to talk about the part that's harder to put on a spreadsheet. Why do so many owners wait so long to decide?

I Closed a Business, Too

I'll start with my own.

I once owned a marketing firm. It wasn't unsuccessful. We had good clients and did good work. But it was always tight. Every month felt like a balancing act, and the stress and pressure were a lot more than the results.

Then a client who worked with another marketing firm and publication offered me a full-time job. I took it, and I slowly closed my own business. A few clients moved over to freelance work with me. Others moved to the company I was joining.

It wasn't a bad business. The numbers just didn't work for me at that time.

I don't look back on that as a failure. I look back on it as a decision, and I'm glad I made it while I still had good options instead of waiting until I didn't have any.

"Broken" Doesn't Mean You Broke It

This week's fictional owner, Bob, runs a retail boutique. His sales have dropped by about 30% over the last few years, mostly because his regulars now buy the same things online. He's put about $40,000 of his own savings into the store to cover the gap.

When we talk about a "broken model," it can sound like Bob did something wrong. In his case, he really didn't. His customers changed how they shop. No one could have stopped that.

As Nick put it, a broken model just means that what was working before doesn't work now.

That difference matters, because shame makes people freeze. If you believe the business struggling means you failed, you'll do almost anything to avoid looking at it. If you understand that the world shifted underneath you, you can start asking better questions.

And one of the first questions is whether you need to close at all, or whether you need to change.

For Bob, my answer was immediate. His customers went online, so he needs to go online too. I know of a boutique that kept a storefront because the owner loved decorating it and seeing her customers, but about 95% of its sales came through the website. The store was the part she enjoyed. The website was what kept it running.

If Bob has been watching sales drop for years and nobody has asked him, "Why aren't you selling online?", that tells me he doesn't have anyone in his corner. And before you close, you should know you've actually tried everything.

Thinking Ahead Instead of Holding On

A former boss of mine built his building about 15 years ago on a side of town where there was basically nothing. A medical office and that was about it. The anchor grocery store and the post office were on the other side of town, and that's where everything was happening.

People thought he was crazy.

Nobody could have known exactly how the town would change. But he had looked at the planning and believed the town would grow outward, toward the interstate, instead of inward.

He was right. The old grocery store on the other side of town has since closed, and that building sits empty. Today, the anchor grocery store and the post office are both near where he built, right in the middle of where everything is.

Nick made a point I agree with: that wasn't luck. He thought it through and planned ahead. He was asking what his business would need three to five years from now, not just whether it was getting through this month.

Most owners who end up closing don't run out of money first. They run out of time to think about it, because they waited until the bank balance made the decision for them.

Sometimes the Problem Is You

This is the hardest one, and I said it on the show knowing it would sting a little: sometimes the problem with the business is the owner.

I worked for someone once at a job I truly loved. As a person, I have a lot of fondness for him. He is very good at what he does. But he isn't great at running a business, and he couldn't get out of his own way. I still believe his company would take off if he did.

That's not a character flaw. Being great at the work and being great at running the business are two different skills, and very few people start out with both.

Nick put it well. Maybe you're not meant to be a plumber, but that doesn't mean you can't be successful running a business. Starting over or changing direction isn't failing. It might be an expensive lesson, but you take everything you learned with you.

There's a trend going around online where teachers tell their students, "You skipped the part where you try." That one stuck with me. The goal isn't to never fail. It's to keep trying, keep learning, and be honest about what isn't working.

Don't Make This Decision Alone

If there's one thing Nick and I kept coming back to, it's that too many owners are on an island.

There's a lot of ego tied up in owning a business, and closing can feel shameful. So owners make decisions alone that keep things going longer than they should. As Nick said, if they'd had someone to talk to, that person might have told them six months earlier, "This isn't working, and here's probably why."

That person doesn't have to be us. It could be an accountant, an advisor, or another business owner in a completely different industry. Nick said he's never met a successful business owner who didn't have people to bounce ideas off of. Sometimes just saying it out loud helps you see where the holes in your plan are.

The Decision Is Yours. Make It on Purpose.

Closing my marketing firm was the right call for me. Building on the empty side of town was the right call for my former boss. For Bob, the right call might be a website, a smaller store, or a fresh start somewhere else.

None of those are failures. The only real mistake is letting the decision get made for you.

So here's what I'd ask you to do this week. Think of one person you could be completely honest with about how your business is really doing. Then call them.

And if you want the numbers side of this decision, Nick has a simple exercise for that too: write down the most you'd ever put into your business from your own pocket, and decide it while you're calm.

Watch the Conversation

In this episode of the Planting Seeds Podcast, Nick and I talk about how to tell a bad season from a broken model, why you should pick your number before you need it, when to pivot instead of close, the lessons owners usually learn the hard way, and how a local shop can compete when customers move online.

Watch now

At Harvest Advisory Group, we help business owners take an honest look at what's working and what isn't, before the money makes the decision for them.

Because closing isn't the failure. Not deciding is.

Previous
Previous

How Much Should I Pay Myself From My Business? Start With What Your Job Is Worth

Next
Next

When Should I Close My Business? How to Tell a Bad Season From a Broken Model